What is the rule of thumb for which solutes will dissolve in which solvents?

Solutions are a special kind of mixture. Solubility is a term used to describe the amount of materials (solids, liquids, or gas) which can be dissolved in a solvent to make a solution. The research aspect of this science fair project is to test the solubility of several common liquid substances.

Show

What are the goals?

Several common liquids, such as water, rubbing alcohol, and club soda, will have solids such as salts, sand, and baking soda added to them to determine which solids dissolve in which liquids at room temperature. Based on the results of this investigation a data table will be prepared and the results potted on a series of graphs. A rule of thumb for solubility in solvents is "like dissolves like." This means that in general, polar compounds are soluble in polar solvents and non-polar compounds are soluble in non-polar solvents. One practical benefit of the results of this project is to prove or disprove this rule.

  • What is a solvent?
  • What is a solute?
  • Which solvent was able to dissolve most or all of the solutes?
  • Which solute was the most soluble in the solvents tested?
  • The term "universal solvent" means ability to dissolve most substances. Which solvent tested would fits this description?

Solutions are a special kind of mixture. Solubility is a term used to describe the amount of materials (solids, liquids, or gas) which can be dissolved in a solvent to make a solution. A solvent is the dissolving agent, e.g. water. A solute is a substance that is dissolved in a solution.

In this science fair project, solutions in which the solvent is a liquid will be investigated. Most liquid solvents are molecular compounds. Whether a compound will dissolve in a particular solvent depends on what that solvent is. The rule of thumb for solubility in molecular solvents is "like dissolves like." This means that in general, polar compounds (chemical compounds whose molecules exhibit electrically positive characteristics at one extremity and negative characteristics at the other) are soluble in polar solvents and non-polar compounds are soluble in nonpolar solvents. Water is an example of a polar solvent. Cooking oil is an example of a nonpolar solvent. Water is the most commonly used liquid solvent. It is sometimes called the "universal solvent" because it can dissolve more substances than any other liquid.

What materials are required?

Rubbing alcohol, club soda, cooking oil, table salt, baking soda, table sugar, Epsom salt, package of plastic drinking cups, coffee stirrers, metric measuring cup, clean playground or beach sand, and rubber or Latex disposable gloves

Where can the materials be found?

All of the items for this project can be a purchased locally at most major retail stores (Walmart, Target, dollar stores, etc).

  1. On a sheet of paper or with the use of a computer and printer draw a table similar to the one shown below.
  2. Using a graduated measuring cup, measure out 10 ml of water and pour into a cup.
  3. Measure out a teaspoon of table salt and add it to the cup of water and stir using a coffee stirrer.
  4. If all of the salt (solute) disappears then the solute is said to have dissolved in the solvent and a solution is produce. An insoluble solute will settle out of the mixture. Insoluble solutes are usually found at the bottom of the cup or floating on the surface of the liquid.
  5. Record the results of each test by writing the words "soluble" if the entire solid dissolves, "insoluble" if the solid does not dissolve, or "partially soluble" if some of the solid dissolves.
  6. In another clean cup add 10 ml of water, but this time add a teaspoon of sand and stir. Record the results in the table.
  7. Repeat the same procedure for the Epsom salt, baking soda, and sugar. Each time used a clean cup and coffee stirrer.
  8. Follow the same procedure with the rubbing alcohol, club water, and cooking oil in place of the water.
 Solvents  Solutes        
   Table Salt  Baking Soda  Sand  Table Sugar Epsom Salt
 Water          
 Alchohol          
 Club Soda          
 Cooking Oil          
  1. Using graph paper, visually display the data in the table by plotting a bar graph similar to the one shown with the names of the solutes along the horizontal axis and the solubility ratings in water along the vertical axis. Repeat this same procedure for each solvent tested.           

    What is the rule of thumb for which solutes will dissolve in which solvents?

Terms/Concepts: Solution; solubility; solvent; solute; polar compound

References:

References to related books

Title: Janice VanCleave's Chemistry for Every Kid: 101 Easy Experiments that Really Work

Author: Janice VanCleave

Publisher: Jossey-Bass. Inc. ISBN-10: 0471620858 and ISBN-13: 978-0471620853

This book contains many experiments design to be conducted by elementary and middle school science age children. It also explains basic chemistry concepts that will be useful in conducting this science fair project.

Links to related sites on the web

Title: Solubility of Salts

URL: http://www.elmhurst.edu/~chm/vchembook/171solublesalts.html

Title: What is Solubility?

URL: http://www.chemistryland.com/CHM107/Water/WaterTutorial.htm

NOTE: The Internet is dynamic; websites cited are subject to change without warning or notice!

Disclaimer and Safety Precautions Education.com provides the Science Fair Project Ideas for informational purposes only. Education.com does not make any guarantee or representation regarding the Science Fair Project Ideas and is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage, directly or indirectly, caused by your use of such information. By accessing the Science Fair Project Ideas, you waive and renounce any claims against Education.com that arise thereof. In addition, your access to Education.com's website and Science Fair Project Ideas is covered by Education.com's Privacy Policy and site Terms of Use, which include limitations on Education.com's liability.

Warning is hereby given that not all Project Ideas are appropriate for all individuals or in all circumstances. Implementation of any Science Project Idea should be undertaken only in appropriate settings and with appropriate parental or other supervision. Reading and following the safety precautions of all materials used in a project is the sole responsibility of each individual. For further information, consult your state's handbook of Science Safety.

Learning Objectives

  • Predict solubility based on interactions between solute and solvent.

What occurs at the molecular level to cause a solute to dissolve in a solvent? The answer depends in part on the strength of attractions between solute and solvent particles. A good rule of thumb is to use is like dissolves like, which means that substances must have similar intermolecular forces to form solutions.

A substance can dissolve in a solvent, and form a solution, if the solute and solvent are attracted to each other. For example, water molecules that are held together by hydrogen bonding will dissolve solutes that can also hydrogen bond, like ethanol (CH3CH2OH). The new hydrogen bonds between the water and the ethanol molecules (solvent-solute attractions) are nearly as strong as the hydrogen bonds in water (solvent-solvent) and ethanol (solute-solute) alone, making the process of solution formation (also called dissolution or dissolving) favorable.

In the case of a solid or liquid solute, the interactions between the solute particles and the solvent particles are so strong that the individual solute particles separate from each other and, surrounded by solvent molecules. (Gaseous solutes already have their constituent particles separated, but the concept of being surrounded by solvent particles still applies.) This process is called solvation and is illustrated in Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\). When the solvent is water, the word hydration, rather than solvation, is used.

When a solute and solvent that do not have similar intermolecular forces are mixed, a solution is not formed because the solute-solute or solvent-solvent attractions are stronger than any favorable interactions between solute and solvent. For example when water and oil are mixed, they will stay in separate layers: the water molecules remain hydrogen bonded to each other and the oil molecules stay together.

What is the rule of thumb for which solutes will dissolve in which solvents?
Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Solvation. When a solute dissolves, the individual particles of solute become surrounded by solvent particles. Eventually the particle detaches from the remaining solute, surrounded by solvent molecules in solution. Source: Photo © Thinkstock

In the case of molecular solutes like glucose, the solute particles are individual molecules. However, if the solute is ionic, the individual ions separate from each other and become surrounded by solvent particles. The positively charged cations are attracted to the neg and anions of an ionic solute separate when the solute dissolves. This process is referred to as dissociation (Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\)).

The dissociation of soluble ionic compounds gives solutions of these compounds an interesting property: they conduct electricity. Because of this property, soluble ionic compounds are referred to as electrolytes. Many ionic compounds dissociate completely and are therefore called strong electrolytes. Sodium chloride is an example of a strong electrolyte. Some compounds dissolve but dissociate only partially, and solutions of such solutes may conduct electricity only weakly. These solutes are called weak electrolytes. Acetic acid (CH3COOH), the compound in vinegar, is a weak electrolyte. Solutes that dissolve into individual neutral molecules without dissociation do not impart additional electrical conductivity to their solutions and are called nonelectrolytes. Table sugar (C12H22O11) is an example of a nonelectrolyte.

The term electrolyte is used in medicine to mean any of the important ions that are dissolved in aqueous solution in the body. Important physiological electrolytes include Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2+, and Cl−.

The following substances all dissolve to some extent in water. Classify each as an electrolyte or a nonelectrolyte.

  1. potassium chloride (KCl)
  2. fructose (C6H12O6)
  3. isopropyl alcohol [CH3CH(OH)CH3]
  4. magnesium hydroxide [Mg(OH)2]

Each substance can be classified as an ionic solute or a nonionic solute. Ionic solutes are electrolytes, and nonionic solutes are nonelectrolytes.

  1. Potassium chloride is an ionic compound; therefore, when it dissolves, its ions separate, making it an electrolyte.
  2. Fructose is a sugar similar to glucose. (In fact, it has the same molecular formula as glucose.) Because it is a molecular compound, we expect it to be a nonelectrolyte.
  3. Isopropyl alcohol is an organic molecule containing the alcohol functional group. The bonding in the compound is all covalent, so when isopropyl alcohol dissolves, it separates into individual molecules but not ions. Thus, it is a nonelectrolyte
  4. Magnesium hydroxide is an ionic compound, so when it dissolves it dissociates. Thus, magnesium hydroxide is an electrolyte.

The following substances all dissolve to some extent in water. Classify each as an electrolyte or a nonelectrolyte.

  1. acetone (CH3COCH3)
  2. iron(III) nitrate [Fe(NO3)3]
  3. elemental bromine (Br2)
  4. sodium hydroxide (NaOH)
Answer

a. nonelectrolyte

b. electrolyte

c. nonelectrolyte

d. electrolyte

Our body fluids are solutions of electrolytes and many other things. The combination of blood and the circulatory system is the river of life, because it coordinates all the life functions. When the heart stops pumping in a heart attack, the life ends quickly. Getting the heart restarted as soon as one can is crucial in order to maintain life.

The primary electrolytes required in the body fluid are cations (of calcium, potassium, sodium, and magnesium) and anions (of chloride, carbonates, aminoacetates, phosphates, and iodide). These are nutritionally called macrominerals.

Electrolyte balance is crucial to many body functions. Here's some extreme examples of what can happen with an imbalance of electrolytes: elevated potassium levels may result in cardiac arrhythmias; decreased extracellular potassium produces paralysis; excessive extracellular sodium causes fluid retention; and decreased plasma calcium and magnesium can produce muscle spasms of the extremities.

When a patient is dehydrated, a carefully prepared (commercially available) electrolyte solution is required to maintain health and well being. In terms of child health, oral electrolyte is given when a child is dehydrated due to diarrhea. The use of oral electrolyte maintenance solutions, which is responsible for saving millions of lives worldwide over the last 25 years, is one of the most important medical advances in protecting the health of children in the century, explains Juilus G.K. Goepp, MD, assistant director of the Pediatric Emergency Department of the Children's Center at Johns Hopkins Hospital. If a parent provides an oral electrolyte maintenance solution at the very start of the illness, dehydration can be prevented. The functionality of electrolyte solutions is related to their properties, and interest in electrolyte solutions goes far beyond chemistry.

Sports drinks are designed to rehydrate the body after excessive fluid depletion. Electrolytes in particular promote normal rehydration to prevent fatigue during physical exertion. Are they a good choice for achieving the recommended fluid intake? Are they performance and endurance enhancers like they claim? Who should drink them?

Typically, eight ounces of a sports drink provides between fifty and eighty calories and 14 to 17 grams of carbohydrate, mostly in the form of simple sugars. Sodium and potassium are the most commonly included electrolytes in sports drinks, with the levels of these in sports drinks being highly variable. The American College of Sports Medicine says a sports drink should contain 125 milligrams of sodium per 8 ounces as it is helpful in replenishing some of the sodium lost in sweat and promotes fluid uptake in the small intestine, improving hydration.

In the summer of 1965, the assistant football coach of the University of Florida Gators requested scientists affiliated with the university study why the withering heat

What is the rule of thumb for which solutes will dissolve in which solvents?
of Florida caused so many heat-related illnesses in football players and provide a solution to increase athletic performance and recovery post-training or game. The discovery was that inadequate replenishment of fluids, carbohydrates, and electrolytes was the reason for the “wilting” of their football players. Based on their research, the scientists concocted a drink for the football players containing water, carbohydrates, and electrolytes and called it “Gatorade.” In the next football season the Gators were nine and two and won the Orange Bowl. The Gators’ success launched the sports-drink industry, which is now a multibillion-dollar industry that is still dominated by Gatorade.

University of Florida football player Chip Hinton testing Gatorade in 1965, pictured next to the leader of its team of inventors, Robert Cade.

Concept Review Exercise

  1. Explain how the solvation process describes the dissolution of a solute in a solvent.

Answer

  1. Each particle of the solute is surrounded by particles of the solvent, carrying the solute from its original phase.

Key Takeaway

  • When a solute dissolves, its individual particles are surrounded by solvent molecules and are separated from each other.

Exercises

  1. Describe what happens when an ionic solute like Na2SO4 dissolves in a polar solvent.

  2. Describe what happens when a molecular solute like sucrose (C12H22O11) dissolves in a polar solvent.

  3. Classify each substance as an electrolyte or a nonelectrolyte. Each substance dissolves in H2O to some extent.

  4. Classify each substance as an electrolyte or a nonelectrolyte. Each substance dissolves in H2O to some extent.

    1. CH3CH2CH2OH
    2. Ca(CH3CO2)2
    3. I2
    4. KOH

  5. Will solutions of each solute conduct electricity when dissolved?

  6. Will solutions of each solute conduct electricity when dissolved?

    1. CH3COCH3
    2. N(CH3)3
    3. CH3CO2C2H5
    4. FeCl2

  1. Each ion of the ionic solute is surrounded by particles of solvent, carrying the ion from its associated crystal.

2. Each sucrose molecule is surrounded by solvent molecules (attracted to each other via intermolecular forces of attraction).
    1. electrolyte
    2. nonelectrolyte
    3. nonelectrolyte
    4. electrolyte

4.
  • nonelectrolyte
  • electrolyte
  • nonelectrolyte
  • electrolyte

5.

6.

a. no

b. no

c. no

d. yes